Article

September 2024

SearchGPT vs Google: Is AI-powered search the future?

Video - September 2024

SearchGPT vs Google: Is AI-powered search the future?

Can generative AI transform your business? Download our report now and get exclusive insights from the top CIOs.

For years, Google has dominated online search. Its popularity is so ingrained that “to Google it” is synonymous with searching the web. However, OpenAI’s recently launched SearchGPT prototype, an AI-powered search engine, now presents a potential alternative.

The big question remains: Is SearchGPT just another hype or a genuine contender to Google? With its advanced AI capabilities, many wonder if it will challenge Google’s dominance. As users explore this new tool, the future of search engines is now in question.

What is SearchGPT?

OpenAI’s prototype, SearchGPT, is an AI-powered search engine that combines AI models with web information to provide fast and accurate answers. Users can ask questions using natural language, and SearchGPT will provide up-to-date information while citing relevant sources. It also allows users to ask follow-up questions and makes the search experience similar to having a conversation with another person.

How can you access SearchGPT?

You can access SearchGPT by visiting chatgpt.com/search. To join the SearchGPT waitlist, you must be logged into a free or premium ChatGPT account. If selected, you’ll receive an email with further instructions. At the moment, the waitlist is closed until further notice.

Key features of SearchGPT:

Here are some of the core features of OpenAI SearchGPT that make it different from traditional search engines:

SearchGPT features

  • AI-powered search: SearchGPT combines AI models with real-time web data for quick and accurate answers. Answers are direct and clear, and relevant sources are included in every result.
  • Conversational search: SearchGPT allows users to ask questions in natural language and easily follow up for clarity. This conversational approach enhances the experience by providing more accurate and relevant results. It mimics natural conversation, making the search process feel similar to having a conversation with a human.
  • Citations and source links: SearchGPT prominently cites and links to sources within its responses. Users can easily verify the origin of the information they receive.
  • Publisher partnerships: OpenAI collaborates with publishers and creators to enhance content visibility in search results. Publishers can manage how their content appears in SearchGPT.
  • Feedback-driven development: The SearchGPT prototype is open to a select group for feedback to improve the product. OpenAI will refine the system based on user and publisher input. The best features will later be integrated into ChatGPT for a more comprehensive experience.

SearchGPT vs Google Search: What are the major differences?

This section explores the key differences between SearchGPT and Google Search in terms of how they deliver search results and handle information.

SearchGPT vs Google: Comparing features

Conversation-based vs query-based search

SearchGPT: SearchGPT offers a conversation-based approach, allowing users to ask questions in natural language. Users can also ask follow-up questions, just like in a conversation with another person. The process feels more dynamic as SearchGPT improves answers based on the ongoing conversation.

Google: Google relies on a traditional query-based system, where users enter specific keywords. The Google search results are presented as a list of web pages related to those terms. This approach is more static, requiring users to adjust keywords for better results.

Real-time information vs crawling all web pages

SearchGPT: SearchGPT provides real-time information by pulling data from live web sources. This ensures users receive the most up-to-date content on the searched topics.

Google: Google, on the other hand, relies on crawling its vast index of web pages. This comprehensive database may sometimes include older or irrelevant information.

Concise answers vs list of website links

SearchGPT: SearchGPT provides concise and direct answers by summarizing information from multiple sources into one response. It clearly cites these sources, making verification easy for users seeking trusted details. This saves time by reducing the need to browse through multiple websites.

Google: Google displays a list of links to web pages, requiring users to find answers themselves. This approach offers more options but often leads to more time spent searching. Users need to click through links to gather relevant information from different sources.

Ad-free experience vs Google ads

SearchGPT: SearchGPT currently offers users an ad-free experience. This improves user experience by reducing distractions from sponsored content. Future plans may involve subscriptions or extra charges, but for now, it remains ad-free.

Google: Google, however, displays ads in search results, with top results often being paid listings. It drives revenue through user clicks on the displayed ads, and in 2023 alone, it generated 237.86 billion USD. This advertising model often leads to sponsored content taking priority over organic results.

OpenAI’s architecture vs Google’s algorithms

SearchGPT: SearchGPT uses OpenAI’s architecture, which excels in understanding and generating human-like text. It doesn’t rely on web crawlers or indexing but instead processes user queries through deep learning. This helps to provide more context-driven and conversational answers.

Google: Google relies on its PageRank algorithm and machine learning techniques to rank web pages. It uses web crawlers to index the internet and assess page quality and relevance. Google’s algorithm continuously evolves, factoring in user behavior and personalization for accurate search results.

How is SearchGPT different from Google AI overviews?

While SearchGPT focuses on providing detailed information and reliable sourcing, Google AI Overviews offer quick summaries. Below are some notable differences between the two:

SearchGPT vs Google AI Overviews: Comparing features

Depth of information:

  • SearchGPT draws from multiple sources and often includes multimedia for comprehensive answers.
  • Google AI Overviews only provides summaries and guides users to relevant links for more details.

Information verification:

  • SearchGPT provides clear citations with direct links to the original sources.
  • Google AI Overviews offer links, but attribution may not be as direct or obvious.

Interactivity and engagement:

  • SearchGPT allows users to engage through follow-up questions and retains context.
  • Google AI Overviews generally offer a single, non-interactive response without further conversation.

Content control:

  • SearchGPT offers transparency for publishers, allowing them to control how their content is used.
  • Google AI Overviews do not provide as much clarity on how content is chosen or summarized.

What is the SearchGPT sidebar?

The SearchGPT sidebar is an important tool for accessing information quickly and provides relevant summaries, images, and videos. It displays source links that allow users to verify the content and explore further. This feature helps users stay engaged without leaving the current page they are on. With real-time information displayed, users can refine their search using follow-up questions easily. Moreover, publishers can control how their content is shown in the SearchGPT sidebar.

SearchGPT vs ChatGPT: How are they different?

SearchGPT is designed specifically for search tasks, using real-time web data to provide accurate and timely answers with direct citations. Instead of real-time search results, ChatGPT is more helpful for everyday tasks like generating content, writing emails, coding, and interpreting data.

While ChatGPT can also perform web searches through Bing, it primarily relies on its training data, which was last updated in April 2023. This means its information might not always be current or accurate for fact-based queries.

SearchGPT vs Perplexity: Which AI search engine is better?

Although SearchGPT and Perplexity both are AI powered search engines, they have some key differences:

Understanding user queries

Sometimes, users don’t frame their questions well and write incomplete search queries. For example, a user might ask, “Can’t login Facebook account help!” This question is vague and lacks specificity. Perplexity AI might struggle interpreting this query due to its standard search algorithms. However, SearchGPT could analyze the intent behind the poorly framed question using advanced language processing and provide relevant suggestions.

Providing responses

Perplexity AI summarizes information from diverse sources, offering quick, reliable insights. SearchGPT combines traditional search engine data with generated summaries for richer responses. It may also personalize answers based on user preferences, adding value for exploratory searches. This interaction creates a more intuitive search experience for users seeking detailed answers.

Personalized experience

Users seeking fast results with simple, clear queries may prefer Perplexity AI. It is effective for tasks like academic research or fact-checking without requiring personalized insights. SearchGPT caters to users who need deeper exploration or contextual explanations on topics. This feature makes it ideal for understanding complex subjects or personalized content.

Key challenges SearchGPT could encounter:

SearchGPT faces strong competition from established search engines like Google and newer AI-driven platforms like Perplexity. Google’s dominance stems from its vast infrastructure, integrated services, and newly introduced AI features, making it hard for new search engines to break through. Perplexity, an emerging platform, offers a feature-rich experience with its dynamic interface and business-specific search solutions.

Despite the competition, SearchGPT has its own strengths, including real-time data retrieval, conversational responses, and clear source attribution. These features give SearchGPT a competitive edge, especially for users seeking transparency and quick answers. To stand out, SearchGPT will need to further differentiate itself by building trust with users and adapting to changing market trends.

Shifting users from Google

Another hurdle SearchGPT could face is building trust to shift users from Google’s familiar platform. Since Google has entrenched itself as a leader with diverse, user-friendly services, users might be skeptical about transitioning to a new, AI-based model.

People are accustomed to searching on Google through keywords. It will take something exceptional for these users to shift from a familiar search engine to an AI-powered model. To address this, SearchGPT must provide consistent and reliable responses that can match or surpass the search engine accuracy users expect from Google.

Concerns about data privacy

SearchGPT, like many AI models, is grappling with data privacy issues that stem from past controversies. These issues include backlash from publishers who fear that AI crawlers might misuse their content. As a result, several leading content providers have restricted access to their online resources.

This restriction poses a challenge for SearchGPT, which relies on extensive web data to refine its responses and user interactions. Concerns are further amplified by instances where data was not adequately protected, like the plaintext storage issue with ChatGPT. OpenAI has responded by enhancing transparency about data use and improving user privacy controls.

Despite these improvements, the question remains about the trustworthiness of these measures in the eyes of users and content creators. Sustained efforts to maintain strong privacy standards are critical to regaining and maintaining this trust. The ongoing evolution of these protocols will likely determine SearchGPT’s ability to access diverse and robust web content in the future.

Legal and regulatory considerations

As AI technologies like SearchGPT evolve, legal and regulatory challenges become more prominent. Different regions enforce varying governance models, which complicates global deployment. For instance, the European Union employs comprehensive AI regulations like the EU AI Act, while the US has existing federal laws that could govern the use of AI.
Moreover, maintaining compliance with these dynamic regulations poses a challenge for AI developers and providers. Companies must monitor and adapt to these changes to avoid legal issues like copyright infringements and privacy concerns. Successfully addressing these limitations of AI is critical for sustaining corporate trust and avoiding financial repercussions.

What do experts think about SearchGPT?

Experts like Dino Gane-Palmer, Neil Patel, and Alex Northstar, among others, offer varying opinions on the impact of SearchGPT. Their opinions reflect a spectrum of enthusiasm and skepticism about its potential effects.

Dino Gane-Palmer – CEO at PreScouter

Dino Gane-Palmer's thoughts about SearchGPT

Image Source

Dino Gane-Palmer views SearchGPT as an advancement in search technology that will improve online searches through conversational interactions. He praises SearchGPT for its ability to provide immediate, accurate answers and direct source links. Moreover, Dino also states that the advanced AI features of SearchGPT could benefit content creators and publishers.

Neil Patel – Co-founder at Neil Patel Digital

Neil Patel's thoughts about SearchGPT

Image Source

Neil Patel suggests that the success of ChatGPT does not automatically translate to the success of SearchGPT. He views SearchGPT as a tool that, while functional, lacks groundbreaking features to lure users away from Google. Patel implies that SearchGPT, being in its early stages, does not yet offer a compelling alternative.

Prof. Marek Kowalkiewicz – Best selling author

Marek Kowalkiewicz's thoughts about SearchGPT

Image Source

Prof. Marek Kowalkiewicz, the bestselling author of “The Economy of Algorithms: AI and the Rise of the Digital Minions,” recently shared his experience with SearchGPT. Over a two-week period, he found that the tool occasionally delivered unexpected or irrelevant responses, which led to a sense of misunderstanding. Kowalkiewicz attributes this to a discrepancy between his expectations and the actual performance of the search tool.

Alex Northstar – AI automation and performance consultant

Alex Northstar's thoughts about SearchGPT

Image Source

Alex Northstar views SearchGPT as a strong contender in the search engine market, challenging Google’s dominance. He believes that Perplexity, another AI-powered search engine, is already succeeding by focusing on providing direct answers rather than links and advertisements. Northstar suggests that SearchGPT’s approach aligns with this trend, which could help it give tough competition to traditional search engines.

Michael Lin – Founder and CEO of Wonders.ai

Michael Lin's thoughts about SearchGPT

Image Source

Michael Lin presents an optimistic view of SearchGPT as a formidable new entrant in the search engine landscape, poised to challenge Google’s dominance. He states how SearchGPT uses OpenAI’s GPT-4 technology to deliver real-time information and accurate answers directly from the web, enhancing the user search experience by providing concise and relevant results.

How will SearchGPT impact marketers?

The shift from link-based search results to direct answers through SearchGPT presents a challenge for marketers. Traditionally, organic traffic has been a key driver for brands supported by popular search engines like Google. With fewer clicks on external links, marketers may face reduced traffic, affecting their reach and engagement strategies.

To adapt, marketers must explore new ways to maintain visibility within this direct-answer ecosystem. SearchGPT’s transparency in citing sources can help brands still appear in results, but traditional click-through models may no longer be enough. Marketers must consider strategies that optimize content for these new search formats.

Moreover, the collaboration between SearchGPT and major publishers suggests a new direction for content inclusion. By offering tools that allow publishers to control their presence in search results, SearchGPT provides some balance. However, concerns remain about the long-term effects on revenue for publishers who rely on web traffic.

Staying ahead of market disruption

Marketers using SearchGPT can stay ahead of market disruption by quickly adapting to changes in search behavior. With AI-driven search engines, understanding how user intent shifts becomes critical. Marketers who adjust their strategies early will gain a lead in reaching their target audience effectively.

SearchGPT can also provide real-time insights into customer needs and trends. This data can be used to refine marketing campaigns and improve engagement. Staying informed about these shifts can help marketers stay competitive and responsive in a fast-changing environment.

The new SEO: Context over keywords

SearchGPT is set to change SEO strategies by shifting the focus away from traditional keyword matching. As AI prioritizes context and user intent, marketers will need to ensure content addresses specific queries in depth. This means understanding the nuances of how AI systems interpret information and structuring content accordingly.

Traditional SEO tactics, such as optimizing for specific keywords, may lose some relevance as AI evolves. Instead, marketers will need to focus on producing high-quality, relevant content that answers questions directly. AI will reward content that provides precise, targeted responses to user queries, making the approach more complex.

Impact on digital advertising

SearchGPT’s potential impact on advertising could lead to major changes in how marketers approach digital ads. Traditional search engines like Google rely on displaying multiple ads across search results, but with SearchGPT, fewer results and fewer ad placements could reduce visibility. This shift may push advertisers to rethink how they target users within AI-powered platforms.

With SearchGPT providing more direct answers, marketers must adjust their strategies to stay relevant. The emphasis may move toward integrating ads more naturally into its conversational interface. This will require a focus on ensuring that ads align with the user’s context and needs rather than relying on high ad placement frequency.

As marketers adapt, contextual advertising may become the primary method for reaching audiences. Ads will need to provide value by appearing at the right time, based on the user’s exact query. This approach will shift marketing efforts toward personalized, situation-based advertising, making it crucial for brands to stay flexible in a changing search environment.

When will SearchGPT be released?

OpenAI has introduced only the prototype of SearchGPT at the moment. They have yet to share any details on when the full version will launch. Additionally, there is no information on when SearchGPT’s features will be integrated into ChatGPT.

What’s Next: How soon will AI powered search replace Google?

While Google continues to lead the search engine market, it may be a long time before AI-powered models like SearchGPT can replace it. Google has built a deep user base and developed advanced search algorithms over the years. Shifting users away from this established system will take time and require consistent improvements from AI models.

Traditional search engines may adapt to these trends by incorporating AI features similar to Google’s AI Overviews. By improving search results with AI capabilities, they can maintain their competitive edge. This gradual evolution of search technology will likely shape how we interact with search engines moving forward.

The impact of AI on search engines is still uncertain, and only time will reveal how these models will influence search behavior. AI-powered tools like SearchGPT provide new options, but the traditional search approach remains dominant. Whether AI will replace traditional search or simply coexist remains a question for the future.

Interested in generative AI for your business, but not sure where to start? Schedule a complimentary brainstorming session with our AI experts here or email us at ai@prescouter.com

About the author

Never miss an insight
Get insights delivered right to your inbox

Never miss an insight

Get insights delivered right to your inbox
By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime.